top of page
Search

AI Is Helping Merchants Win More Chargebacks. Here's What It Still Can't Do for You.

liveit2giveit
3 days ago
4 min read

If your practice or business takes cards, you've dealt with a chargeback. A patient or customer calls their bank instead of calling you, the money comes out of your account, and you have a short window to prove the charge was legitimate.

Artificial intelligence has moved quickly into chargeback management, and new research shows it's working, at least partly. Merchants that use AI are winning more of their disputes. But the same research points to a gap AI hasn't closed yet: it isn't helping merchants decide which chargebacks are worth fighting in the first place.

For a busy practice or small business without a dedicated disputes team, that decision matters more than you might think.

What the new research found

A joint report from Chargeflow and Juniper Research, The State of Chargeback Management: How AI Is Reshaping Performance, compared merchants that use AI to contest disputes with merchants that don't. As Digital Transactions reported, merchants using AI won a median of 38% of their disputes, compared with 27.75% for merchants not using AI.

That's a meaningful improvement. But Chargeflow's Dan Moshkovich pointed out that AI is making merchants better at the disputes they already choose to fight. It hasn't changed which disputes they pick, or how many. And he says that's "where most of the lost revenue sits unrecovered."

A few other findings stood out:

  • Chargebacks are rising. About 65% of merchants surveyed said their chargeback volume grew over the past 18 months, and 90% of that group saw growth of 10% or more.

  • Evidence wins cases. Chargeflow's own data showed that "item never arrived" disputes were won roughly 1.5 times as often when the merchant had strong evidence, such as proof of delivery.

  • Generic responses fall short. Many automated tools drop whatever evidence they can find into a standard template. That handles volume, but it doesn't build the strongest case. Among enterprise merchants, 45% said incorrect or unsupported evidence was a serious concern.

  • Data quality matters most. Merchants ranked data quality as the top factor when choosing a chargeback provider, because a good decision depends on good dispute history.

In other words, the technology is good at the paperwork. The strategy is still up to you.

Why "which ones to fight" is the real question

Chargebacks aren't a small line item anymore. Datos Insights expects merchants' chargeback-related losses to reach $46.1 billion by 2029, according to Digital Transactions.

Here's what many owners and office managers don't realize:

  • Every dispute takes time. Pulling receipts, signed treatment plans, appointment records, and customer communications isn't free, even if you win.

  • Winning doesn't erase the chargeback from your ratio. Card networks track how many chargebacks you receive. A high ratio can lead to monitoring programs, higher fees, or even losing your merchant account.

  • Some disputes simply aren't winnable. Fighting them costs you twice: once in staff time, and again in the lost funds.

  • The disputes you skip are invisible. Moshkovich's advice is to start tracking the chargebacks you choose not to contest. Most businesses have never counted them, and that's often where the money is.

That's why a smart chargeback strategy has three parts, not one.

A simple framework: Fight, Refund, or Prevent

Fight it when:

  • You have clear proof: a signed receipt or treatment agreement, a chip or tap transaction, appointment records, or tracking showing delivery.

  • The patient or customer agreed to your financial, refund, or cancellation policy, and you can show it.

  • The dollar amount is worth the time it takes to respond.

  • The evidence you have actually matches the reason the cardholder gave.

Refund or accept it when:

  • The customer has a fair point (a billing error, a duplicate charge, a service that wasn't delivered).

  • The amount is small compared with the time it would take to build a response.

  • You're missing key documentation.

Prevent it by:

  • Using a clear billing descriptor. Many chargebacks start simply because someone doesn't recognize your business name on their statement. The industry is paying attention to this, too: Digital Transactions has covered efforts by FIS to make debit descriptors clearer for exactly this reason.

  • Making it easy to reach you. A patient who can get a quick answer or refund from your front desk won't go to their bank.

  • Getting signatures on financial policies and treatment plans before work begins.

  • Taking chip and tap payments instead of keying in card numbers whenever possible.

  • Asking your processor about pre-dispute alerts, which can flag a problem before it becomes a formal chargeback, giving you a chance to refund and protect your ratio.

Not sure whether your setup includes these protections? Ask our team. We're happy to take a look.

Where AI actually helps

None of this means AI isn't worth using. It's genuinely useful for the most time-consuming parts of the job:

  • Pulling transaction data and evidence together automatically

  • Tracking response deadlines so nothing slips through the cracks

  • Matching the right evidence to the right type of dispute

Let the technology handle the paperwork. Keep the strategy (what to fight, what to refund, and what to fix in your business) in human hands.

How the right processing partner fits in

Your merchant services provider should be more than a rate on a statement. At Elite Payment Group, we've supported practices and small businesses since 2009, and we help our merchants:

  • Review chargeback history to spot patterns (a certain service, a certain staff member, a certain time of year)

  • Make sure their billing descriptor is clear and recognizable

  • Set up alert and prevention tools where they make sense

  • Stay PCI compliant and protect their account standing

And if you've never had someone walk you through your processing statement in plain language, we can do that, too.

Ready to get ahead of chargebacks? Contact Elite Payment Group or call (321) 244-3031 for a free review of your current processing setup, including your fees, your chargeback activity, and the tools you may be missing. No pressure and no obligation.

 
 
 

Comments


Elite Payment Group

"Let us help you with all of your merchant processing needs. Contact us today!"​

Elite Payment Group
150 W. Fulton St.
Sanford, FL. 32771

​

Phone: (321) 244-3031
Fax: (407) 641-8431

FOLLOW US

  • LinkedIn
  • Facebook
  • X
  • Instagram

© 2026 Elite Payment Group. All rights reserved.

PCI Security Council

Elite Payment Group is a registered ISO of PNC Bank, N.A., Pittsburgh, PA

Website Designed by Wrashmann

bottom of page